| Name | Detail | Season | Rd | XI | Versus |
|---|
| Day, Eddie | 5/2 inc Hat Trick | 1914-15 | 7 | A | Mentone (2nd) |
| Jackson, Joe | 4/16 inc Hat Trick | 1921-22 | 5 | B | Carnegie (2nd) |
| Jackson, Joe | 6/24 inc Hat Trick | 1924-25 | 10 | B | Caulfield Footballers |
| Chambers, Paris | 4/4 inc Hat Trick | 1926-27 | 1 | U16 | Carnegie Moonyas (2nd) |
| Rice, Ernie | 7/41 inc Double Hat Trick | 1931-32 | 4 | C | Carnegie Traders |
| Wood, Alf | 4/7 inc Hat Trick | 1936-37 | 1 | C | Murrumbeena Footballers |
| Wood, Alf | 6/21 inc Hat Trick | 1936-37 | 2 | B | Tooronga |
| Whelan, Fred | 3/29 inc Hat Trick | 1938-39 | 4 | 5 | Tooronga (2nd) |
| Wood, Alf | 7/25 inc Hat Trick | 1939-40 | 7 | A | Washington (2nd) |
| Cooper, Claude | 4/3 inc Hat Trick | 1945-46 | ? | 5 | Unknown |
| Waterman, R | 4/2 inc Hat Trick | 1945-46 | ? | 5 | Unknown |
| Wight, Doug | ?/? inc Hat Trick | 1945-46 | ? | D | Unknown |
| Wight, Doug | ?/? inc Hat Trick | 1945-46 | ? | D | Unknown (2nd) |
| Wight, Doug | ?/? inc Hat Trick | 1945-46 | ? | D | Unknown |
| Kirk, Tom | 4/18 inc Hat Trick | 1948-49 | GF | B | Washington (2nd) |
| Schrape, Arthur | 9/23 inc Hat Trick | 1949-50 | 6 | A | North Caulfield (2nd) |
| Kirk, Tom | 5/9 inc Hat Trick | 1949-50 | ? | B | Unknown |
| Harwood, Jack | 5/38 inc Hat Trick | 1950-51 | ? | C | Unknown (2nd) |
| Bailey, W | 6/6 inc Hat Trick | 1950-51 | ? | D | Unknown |
| Waterman, Gilbert | 5/4 inc Hat Trick | 1950-51 | ? | D | Unknown (2nd) |
| Macwhirter, Jack | 5/16 inc Hat Trick | 1951-52 | 3 | C | Murrumbeena Footballers (2nd) |
| McNabb, John | 4/7 inc Hat Trick | 1952-53 | 3 | U16 | East Caulfield (2nd) |
| Johnston, Bob | 4/7 inc Hat Trick | 1952-53 | 6 | A | Washington |
| Tuddin, George | 6/42 inc Hat Trick | 1952-53 | 7 | 5 | Caulfield Socials |
| McDermott, Don | 6/18 inc Hat Trick | 1953-54 | 2 | D | Carnegie Socials (2nd) |
| Schrape, Arthur | 5/4 inc Hat Trick | 1954-55 | 2 | 1 | Hampton |
| Watson, Ern | 6/11 inc Hat Trick | 1955-56 | 5 | D | Springvale |
| McAlister, Jack | 5/22 inc Hat Trick | 1955-56 | 9 | 2 | Hampton |
| Calvert, Ted | 5/13 inc Hat Trick | 1955-56 | 12 | 2 | Brighton |
| Schrape, Arthur | 4/20 inc Hat Trick | 1956-57 | 4 | 1 | Brighton (2nd) |
| Johnston, Don | 6/21 inc Double Hat Trick | 1958-59 | 8 | 1 | Bentleigh (2nd) |
| Hardham, Max | 3/19 inc Hat Trick | 1959-60 | 2 | 3 | Ormond (1) |
| Whitelaw, Bill | 3/11 inc Hat Trick | 1959-60 | 7 | U16 | Caulfield RSL (2nd) |
| Johnston, Don | 4/20 inc Hat Trick | 1959-60 | 11 | 2 | Moorabbin (2nd) |
| Johnston, Bob | 4/9 inc Hat Trick | 1960-61 | 7 | 2 | McKinnon (2nd) |
| Killen, Terry | 6/17 inc Hat Trick | 1961-62 | 5 | 4 | Hampton |
| Graham, Alan | 5/1 inc Hat Trick | 1961-62 | 5 | U16 | East Malvern YCW |
| Salmon, Barry | 4/2 inc Hat Trick | 1961-62 | 5 | U16 | East Malvern YCW (2nd) |
| Hardham, Max | 3/19 inc Hat Trick | 1962-63 | 1 | 4 | Hakoah Ajax (2nd) |
| Lean, David | 3/0 inc Hat Trick | 1962-63 | 8 | U16 | East Malvern YCW (2nd) |
| Stevens, Brett | 4/22 inc Hat Trick | 1963-64 | 8 | U16 | Caulfield RSL |
| White, Paul | 4/42 inc Hat Trick | 1965-66 | 4 | 2 | Hampton |
| Rudge, Cliff | 9/24 inc Hat Trick | 1965-66 | GF | 5 | Southern Cross (2nd) |
| Macwhirter, Noel | 8/65 inc Hat Trick | 1966-67 | 9 | 5 | Carnegie South |
| Rudge, Cliff | 8/25 inc Hat Trick | 1966-67 | 11 | 3 | Brighton (2nd) |
| Johnston, Don | 7/16 inc Hat Trick | 1968-69 | 1 | 2 | Richmond Union (2nd) |
| Johnston, Don | 9/39 inc Two Hat Tricks | 1968-69 | 3 | 2 | Latrobe University (2nd) |
| Johnston, Don | 8/36 inc Hat Trick | 1969-70 | 7 | 2 | Richmond Union (2nd) |
| Way, Peter | 7/53 inc Hat Trick | 1969-70 | 8 | 2 | Parkville |
| Barker, Tony | 5/8 inc Hat Trick | 1969-70 | 9 | U16 | South Camberwell (2nd) |
| Ricato, John | 5/23 inc Hat Trick | 1972-73 | 3 | 4 | Ormond |
| Weaver, Daryl | 4/43 inc Hat Trick | 1972-73 | 6 | 5 | Bentleigh ANA |
| Saker, Peter | 3/17 inc Hat Trick | 1973-74 | 3 | U16 | Moorabbin Youth Club (2nd) |
| Hayes, Harry | 6/49 inc Hat Trick | 1973-74 | 8 | 3 | Highett |
| Hay, Geoff | 4/16 inc Hat Trick | 1974-75 | 9 | U16 | Highett West (2nd) |
| Cummins, Kevin | 5/17 inc Double Hat Trick | 1976-77 | 1 | 5 | St Anthonys |
| Morison, Leigh | 4/9 inc Hat Trick | 1976-77 | 8 | 2 | McKinnon |
| Russell, Gary | 4/14 inc Hat Trick | 1978-79 | 8 | U16 | Oakleigh |
| Krivaci, Charlie | 5/23 inc Hat Trick | 1983-84 | 2 | U14 | Waverley |
| Walker, Ian | 4/34 inc Hat Trick | 1983-84 | 11 | 3 | Brighton East |
| Bannon, Chris | 4/16 inc Hat Trick | 1985-86 | 6 | U16 | East Oakleigh (2nd) |
| Paton, Nick | 6/4 inc Hat Trick | 1986-87 | 1 | U14 | Princes Park |
| Wilkinson, David | 6/39 inc Hat Trick | 1987-88 | 2 | 2 | North Caulfield Glenhuntly |
| Pyrgolios, Emmanual | 4/11 inc Hat Trick | 1987-88 | 9 | U14 | Mazenod |
| Gange, John | 4/32 inc Hat Trick | 1988-89 | 5 | 5 | East Oakleigh |
| Obee, Richard | 4/8 inc Hat Trick | 1989-90 | 5 | U16 | Trinity |
| Allamby, David | 3/35 inc Hat Trick | 1993-94 | 12 | 2 | Spotswood |
| Price, Adam | 6/50 inc Hat Trick | 1994-95 | 8 | 4 | Bentleigh |
| Gray, Rob | 5/15 inc Hat Trick | 1994-95 | 11 | 4 | Cheltenham |
| Sherman, Matthew | 5/11 inc Hat Trick | 1997-98 | 9 | U12 | Mt Waverley Mayfield Green |
| Wilkinson, David | 5/25 inc Hat Trick | 1997-98 | SF | 4 | Maccabi Ajax |
| Hardham, Brett | 3/36 inc Hat Trick | 1999-00 | 8 | 4 | St Johns/St Bedes |
| Groarke, Christian | 5/11 inc Hat Trick | 2001-02 | 2 | U16 | Mt Waverley Mayfield |
| Thornton, Sean | 4/12 inc Hat Trick | 2001-02 | 8 | 4 | Chelsea |
| Groarke, Christian | 4/4 inc Hat Trick | 2001-02 | 18 | 4 | East Malvern |
| Turnbull, Patrick | 5/3 inc Hat Trick | 2002-03 | 1 | U12 | Clayton District |
| Pogoriller, Alex | 5/68 inc Hat Trick | 2003-04 | 6 | 3 | Albion |
| Scott, Damian | 5/49 inc Hat Trick | 2004-05 | 9 | 2 | Highett |
| Eden, Tom | 4/24 inc Hat Trick | 2005-06 | 4 | U17 | The Saints |
| Fenton, Brett | 3/6 inc Hat Trick | 2006-07 | 7 | 3 | East Malvern (2nd) |
| Walker, Cameron | 5/7 inc Hat Trick | 2006-07 | 7 | U15 | Malvern |
| Seletto, Nick | 3/1 inc Hat Trick | 2006-07 | 8 | U11 | Mt Waverley Mayfield (2nd) |
| Middag, Rick | 5/22 inc Hat Trick | 2007-08 | 1 | U17 | Toorak-Prahran |
| O'Shannessy, Callum | 3/3 inc Hat Trick | 2010-11 | 2 | U13 | Glen Waverley |
| McMahon, James | 3/14 inc Hat Trick | 2010-11 | 10 | 3 | Parkdale (2nd) |
| Baltas, Alex | 4/0 inc Hat Trick | 2010-11 | 11 | U11 | Maccabi Ajax Raiders |
| Baltas, Alex | 4/3 inc Hat Trick | 2012-13 | 6 | U11 | Glen Iris |
| Erharter, Sebastian | 4/15 inc Hat Trick | 2013-14 | 5 | U13 | Toorak-Prahran - Blue |
| Lee, Jayden | 6/22 inc Hat Trick | 2013-14 | 8 | U17 | Glen Waverley Cougars |
| Hay, Stephen | 4/8 inc Hat Trick | 2013-14 | GF | 4 | Hampton |
| Goold, Zane | 4/50 inc Hat Trick | 2014-15 | 4 | 1 | Carnegie |
| Handley, James | 4/39 inc Hat Trick | 2014-15 | 9 | 1 | Old Mentonians |
| McAuliffe, Harry | 4/2 inc Hat Trick | 2014-15 | 12 | U11 | Malvern Red |
| Lamb, Troy | 5/15 inc Hat Trick | 2014-15 | 14 | 1 | Middle Park (2nd) |
| Ward, Jason | 5/16 inc Hat Trick | 2016-17 | 1 | 4 | McKinnon |
| Hillemacher, Oliver | 3/10 inc Hat Trick | 2016-17 | 14 | U11 | Glen Iris Rojko |
| Gupta, Prayank | 3/34 inc Hat Trick | 2017-18 | 6 | 2 | Carnegie |
| Gupta, Prayank | 5/27 inc Hat Trick | 2017-18 | 11 | 2 | South Caulfield |
| Hooda, Vipin | 6/8 inc Hat Trick | 2017-18 | 14 | 4 | Port Melbourne |
| Venturoni, Daniel | 4/34 inc Hat Trick | 2018-19 | 3 | 2 | Parkdale |
| Gupta, Prayank | 4/23 inc Hat Trick | 2018-19 | 8 | 2 | Middle Park |
| Konda, Pranav Balaj | 4/13 inc Hat Trick | 2019-20 | 2 | U11 | Caulfield Gold |
| Kruger, Brad | 4/17 inc Hat Trick | 2019-20 | 8 | 1 | Aspendale |
| Venturoni, Daniel | 5/22 inc Hat Trick | 2019-20 | 11 | 2 | Hampton |
| Mathyam, Ravi | 3/6 inc Hat Trick | 2019-20 | 17 | 4 | Bayside |
| Brady, Tadhg | 3/5 inc Hat Trick | 2020-21 | 5 | U11 | Malvern Junior Silver |
| Egan, Tom | 4/19 inc Hat Trick | 2020-21 | 10 | U15 | South Caulfield |
| De Rose, Tim | 3/12 inc Hat Trick | 2021-22 | 2 | 4 | Bentleigh |
| Harries, Will | 3/14 inc Hat Trick | 2022-23 | 3 | 9 | Bentleigh |
